Supreme Court allows ICE to factor race, workplace into L.A. raids
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Monday to temporarily allow U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers to use race, native language and place of work to partly justify immigration raids.
The court’s conservative majority granted the administration’s emergency application for a stay on a lower court’s decision, with its three liberal justices dissenting. Though the order was reportedly brief and unsigned, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote a concurring opinion.
“Immigration officers ‘may briefly detain’ an individual ‘for questioning’ if they have ‘a reasonable suspicion, based on specific articulable facts, that the person being questioned … is an alien illegally in the United States,’” Kavanaugh wrote. “The reasonable suspicion inquiry turns on the ‘totality of the particular circumstances.’”
Kavanaugh was responding to U.S. District Judge Maame Frimpong’s order that prohibited ICE officials from using several factors to form reasonable suspicion.
“Defendants may not rely solely on the factors … alone or in combination of” a person’s race or ethnicity, their spoken language or accent, their place of work or their location, according to Frimpong.
While the administration cannot base an immigration stop on someone’s race alone, Kavanaugh said it could, along with other factors, provide a reasonable suspicion, especially since the legal bar for reasonable suspicion is lower than it is for probable cause.
“Reasonable suspicion is a lesser requirement than probable cause and ‘considerably short’ of the preponderance of the evidence standard,” Kavanaugh continued.
The case is currently before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Latest News Stories
Executive Committee Members Decry Roadside Litter, Call for Action Against Garbage Haulers
Mokena Fire District Invests in Station Upgrades, Modernizes Security with Digital Key System
Reversing Biden’s precedent, students complete FAFSA in minutes at beta-testing event
Trump, Zelenskyy to meet Monday in steps toward peace with Russia
Possible ‘agreement’ reached in Trump-Putin meeting; more discussion likely
WATCH: Gun rights supporters celebrate 9th Circuit’s ruling against CA gun rationing law
Feds sue California over emission standards for trucks
Illinois quick hits: ‘Lawsuit inferno’ bill takes effect after Pritzker signed 267 measures Friday
WATCH: UW-authored study on surgery times contradicts CMS basis for reimbursement cuts
State defends gun ban district court ruled unconstitutional
Trump aiming for ceasefire, world awaiting news from Putin summit
Pritzker acts upon 269 bills, vetoes 2, signs ‘lawsuit inferno’ measure